Federal Judge Rules Company Has No Right to Fox River Resort
Sheridan IL | Yorkville Herald
A federal judge has ruled that Vairt Inc. has no legal right to purchase the former Fox River Resort property, delivering a decisive victory to Fox River Resort Club and Silverleaf Resorts LLC in a dispute that has drawn significant public attention across LaSalle County.
The November 13 ruling by U.S. District Judge John J. Tharp Jr. resolves the central legal question raised in litigation first reported by the Yorkville Herald earlier this year: whether Vairt retained any contractual right to acquire the resort property after executing a Mutual Termination and Release Agreement with the sellers.
Judge Tharp concluded that it did not.
"The Court finds that Vairt executed the Termination Agreement and thereby eliminated the PSA," Tharp wrote, referring to the parties' Purchase and Sale Agreement.
The court determined that the Mutual Termination and Release Agreement was valid and enforceable, that the Purchase and Sale Agreement had been terminated, and that Vairt no longer possessed any right to purchase the property located at 2558 N. 3653 Road in Sheridan.
The ruling represents a complete rejection of Vairt's central legal argument that the termination agreement never became effective.
At the heart of the court's analysis were Vairt's own communications following the collapse of the transaction. Judge Tharp pointed to multiple emails in which Vairt representatives expressly acknowledged that the termination agreement had been executed. In a June 24 email cited by the court, Vairt's founder and CEO referred to the "Mutual Termination and Release Agreement executed on June 18, 2026" and stated that "the parties agreed to terminate the Purchase and Sale Agreement."
The court relied heavily on those communications to conclude that Vairt accepted the termination agreement and treated it as binding.
The court also found that Vairt sought to obtain benefits under the agreement. Judge Tharp noted that Vairt demanded the release of earnest money pursuant to the termination agreement and ultimately received a portion of those funds. According to the court, those actions were inconsistent with Vairt's later position that the agreement was unenforceable.
At the center of Vairt's defense was an argument that the termination agreement depended upon the release of escrow funds and therefore never became effective. The judge rejected that argument, finding no evidence that such a condition had ever been agreed to by both parties.
Instead, the court concluded that Vairt attempted to rely on the agreement when advantageous while simultaneously contesting its legal effect in court.
In one of the strongest passages of the opinion, Tharp wrote:
"Vairt wants to have its cake and eat it too: compelling the escrow agent to disburse funds pursuant to the Termination Agreement while arguing that it has no legal effect in front of this Court."
The court further rejected Vairt's request for additional discovery and its contention that a jury trial was necessary. Judge Tharp wrote that the court was "genuinely confused" as to why either would be required because "the record does not demonstrate any factual dispute."
The opinion additionally addressed a claim raised by Vairt during a hearing that the executed termination agreement may have differed from the version signed by the sellers. The court noted that Vairt provided no evidence supporting that assertion. Judge Tharp wrote that Vairt "cannot make this argument without providing any evidence to support it."
As a result of the ruling, the court granted declaratory relief in favor of Fox River Resort Club and Silverleaf Resorts, denied Vairt's motion to compel arbitration, and entered judgment for the plaintiffs.
The court's final order declares:
The Mutual Termination and Release Agreement is a valid and enforceable contract;
The Purchase and Sale Agreement was terminated; and
Vairt has no right to purchase the Fox River Resort property located at 2558 N. 3653 Road in Sheridan.
The decision also carries significance in light of allegations previously reported by the Yorkville Herald regarding Vairt's continued promotion of its proposed "V Resort Living" project after the transaction had collapsed.
Those allegations formed part of the broader dispute between the parties. Court filings cited marketing materials, public presentations, social media posts, investor communications, and other promotional activities that portrayed the project as moving forward despite the sellers' position that the Purchase and Sale Agreement had already been terminated.
Although Judge Tharp did not rule on those marketing allegations, the opinion repeatedly cites communications in which Vairt's executives and attorneys described the termination agreement as executed and binding. The ruling therefore reinforces the sellers' longstanding position that the parties had already agreed to terminate the transaction.
The dispute generated widespread local debate as Vairt promoted plans for a faith-oriented resort development at the property. Public materials described amenities including residential units, resort facilities, fractional ownership opportunities, halal dining, and a mosque. Other materials discussed a Musharakah co-ownership model structured around Sharia-compliant financing principles.
Those development concepts, however, were not addressed by the court and played no role in Judge Tharp's legal analysis. The case before the court focused solely on whether the parties had successfully terminated the Purchase and Sale Agreement and whether Vairt retained any legal right to acquire the property.
Following the ruling, Defend LaSalle, a citizen advocacy organization that had publicly opposed the proposed redevelopment, issued a statement thanking God for the outcome and characterizing the decision as an answer to months of prayer by concerned residents.
“Today, we pause not to celebrate a legal victory, but to give glory and thanks to Almighty God," the organization stated. "For many months, the community has prayed for wisdom, truth, justice, and God's protection over LaSalle County and the Fox River Resort property."
The group further stated that citizens had "brought their concerns before God, petitioning Him in prayer and trusting in His providence," while citing Psalm 34:17: "The righteous cry, and the Lord heareth, and delivereth them out of all their troubles."
Defend LaSalle emphasized that the ruling should be met with humility rather than triumphalism, stating: "This moment should not lead us to boast, but rather to humility. It serves as a reminder that God remains attentive to the cries of His people and that He is faithful in every generation."
While Vairt may still seek review by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, the district court's judgment leaves little uncertainty regarding the status of the transaction.
"The Purchase and Sale Agreement was terminated," Judge Tharp concluded, and "Vairt has no right to purchase the property."